Goals to lower fertility in Africa and South Asia: 2 of 9 came true on time. Pakistan expected 2.6 by 2020 and had 3.77
- Rwanda: 4.5 by 20124.2
- Rwanda: 3.4 by 20184.05
- Rwanda: 3 by 20203.91
- Tanzania: 5 by 20155.03
- Malawi: 3.5 by 20164.22
- Uganda: 4.5 by 20204.62
- Pakistan: 2.6 by 20203.77
- India: 2.1 by 20102.6
- India: 2.1 by 20251.98
Children per woman in the deadline year
2 of 9 came true on time. Pakistan expected 2.6 by 2020 and had 3.77.
Tanzania and Uganda reached their targets two years late, India reached 2.1 ten years late. Rwanda passed its first target, 4.5, but not the later ones.
More
Many high-fertility countries write a goal to lower it into their development plans. Here are nine such goals from six countries beside what came out in the deadline year.
A row is one promise: who, what and by when. The question is whether at least half came true. Answer Yes or No, or just open the answer: each row gets its outcome and what actually came of it, the card a stamp counting those that came true. Quotes and links to the facts are below.
- Pakistan: 2.6 by 2020 — Planning Commission of Pakistan (Nawaz Sharif government), 2014 children per woman
promised 3 by 2020; fact 4 (145%). 2020: 3.77 children per woman (UN estimate) against 2.6.
ООН, World Population Prospects 2024 / UN World Population Prospects 2024
- Rwanda: 3 by 2020 — Government of Rwanda (Paul Kagame), Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning, 2012 children per woman
promised 3 by 2020; fact 4 (130%). 2020: 3.9 children per woman (UN estimate) against 3.
ООН, World Population Prospects 2024 / UN World Population Prospects 2024
- India: 2.1 by 2010 — Government of India (Atal Bihari Vajpayee), 2000 children per woman
promised 2 by 2010; fact 3 (124%). 2010: 2.6 children per woman (UN estimate); 2.1 or below from 2020 (2.05).
ООН, World Population Prospects 2024 / UN World Population Prospects 2024
- Malawi: 3.5 by 2016 — Government of Malawi (Bingu wa Mutharika, then Joyce Banda), 2011 children per woman
promised 4 by 2016; fact 4 (121%). 2016: 4.22 children per woman (UN estimate) against 3.5; 3.65 in 2023.
ООН, World Population Prospects 2024 / UN World Population Prospects 2024
- Rwanda: 3.4 by 2018 — Government of Rwanda (Paul Kagame), Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning, 2013 children per woman
promised 3 by 2018; fact 4 (119%). 2018: 4.05 children per woman (UN estimate) against 3.4; 3.78 in 2022.
ООН, World Population Prospects 2024 / UN World Population Prospects 2024
- Uganda: 4.5 by 2020 — Government of Uganda (Yoweri Museveni), National Planning Authority, 2015 children per woman
promised 5 by 2020; fact 5 (103%). 2020: 4.62 children per woman (UN estimate) against 4.5; below 4.5 from 2022 (4.39).
ООН, World Population Prospects 2024 / UN World Population Prospects 2024
- Tanzania: 5 by 2015 — Government of Tanzania (Jakaya Kikwete), Ministry of Finance and Economic Affairs, 2010 children per woman
promised 5 by 2015; fact 5 (101%). 2015: 5.03 children per woman (UN estimate) against 5.0; below 5.0 from 2017 (4.99).
ООН, World Population Prospects 2024 / UN World Population Prospects 2024
- India: 2.1 by 2025 — Ministry of Health and Family Welfare of India, 2017 children per woman
promised 2 by 2025; fact 2 (94%). For the country as a whole the target was met early: 2.05 in 2020 and 1.98 in 2023 (UN estimates).
ООН, World Population Prospects 2024 / UN World Population Prospects 2024
- Rwanda: 4.5 by 2012 — Government of Rwanda (Paul Kagame), Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning, 2007 children per woman
promised 5 by 2012; fact 4 (93%). 2012: 4.2 children per woman (UN estimate) against a 4.5 target.
ООН, World Population Prospects 2024 / UN World Population Prospects 2024
Targets: verbatim from the development plans of Rwanda, Tanzania, Malawi, Uganda and Pakistan and from India’s population and health policies. Fact: UN estimates (World Population Prospects 2024). Outcome: «came true» — the promised number reached by the deadline («about» within 5%), an event happened before the end of the year promised; «exceeded» — with room to spare; «nearly» — short by no more than 10%; «late» — reached, but after the deadline; «did not come true» — not reached; «came true, then undone» — reached, then reversed. The deadline is the end of the year named.
National surveys give their own numbers, which differ from UN estimates by tenths. Fertility fell in all six countries, but in most more slowly than the plans expected. The data do not show that the plans caused the falls.
A question for this picture
Why did plans so often expect fertility to fall faster than it did?